Feb 23, 2009

Why I make kids draw graphs by hand

I had a really interesting experience in my chemistry I class the other day. We are studying properties of matter and as part of physical properties, we look at changes of state, and graph temperature and time data in an attempt to determine the melting point of a pure substance (stearic acid, comment if you want more info).

My enthusiastic, grade 9 budding Einsteins are asking "can we use computers to draw the graph?". I hesitate for a second before thinking with my 21st century hat on then responding "I would prefer you to hand draw following the instructions you have been given but if you wish to use MS Excel or equivalent that is OK". Stage set.

Jump to graphs being returned to students. Some dismay is evident and I find it very interesting that students, in general, are under the impression that computer generated graphs are somehow worth more marks than hand drawn graphs. As I pointed out errors in presentation and format to one student, his response said it all : "but I used the computer!" was his plea, as if that somehow made an incorrect graph worth more marks.

What were the errors? Here is a partial list of things I saw:
  • line graph chosen (should be x-y scatter plot)
  • inappropriate scale (detail of melting point not visible because software autoscales from zero)
  • HUGE points (points are just that. data points should be tiny and surrounded by what we call in the business "point protectors")
  • inappropriate trend line (computers are notorious for this)
I reflected on this student's comment and started to wonder where is this attitude coming from? Why do my students equate computer with "better" (they do the same with digital instruments vs analog and in almost all cases are entirely incorrect). Encouragement to use technology is happening in classrooms globally but I am wondering if "any use" is better than "less but correct use"?

There are also two learning issues here. The first, is the documented course objective of how to plot data in a correct manner that effectively communicates the data. This is what I am trying to teach. This is why said student was not as successful as he had hoped in terms of how his work was assessed.

The second learning issue is who/where/when are these kids being taught (in the scope of say their science curriculum progression), not only the point of graphing, the principles of graphing but how to use Excel (or other software) correctly. I emphasize the option of using other software because graphing software varies in its appearance but not so much in its function. If the students understand the purpose of the function (in terms of creating the graph - like for example scaling an axis), then the brand of software does not matter. Somewhere (maybe my classroom), this skill is not being formally taught. My issue here goes beyond blogging and wikis, to the real skill which is graphing (or writing - reflectively, or other ways), and how we as educators are inconsistently integrating use of technology (sometimes incorrectly, sometimes ineffectually) and also detrimentally to students, creating the impression that digital media somehow improves the quality (presentation/look excepted) of their work.

Comments on Connectivism






















George Siemens paper "Connectivism: A Learning Theory for a Digital Age" took me quite some time (and more than one read) to digest. I wrote down a number of ideas over a number of days and am just finally getting around to publishing my reflections.
I am not sure how I feel about learning theory in general. As I read this paper, the irony in the Gonzalez (2004) paper quote was not missed:
“One of the most persuasive factors is the shrinking half-life of knowledge. The “half-life of knowledge” is the time span from when knowledge is gained to when it becomes obsolete. Half of what is known today was not known 10 years ago. The amount of knowledge in the world has doubled in the past 10 years and is doubling every 18 months according to the American Society of Training and Documentation (ASTD). To combat the shrinking half-life of knowledge, organizations have been forced to develop new methods of deploying instruction.”

I say irony, because "connectivism" (which I guess is new enough not to pass the MS Word spell checker), is a learning theory and like other knowledge, has a half-life (according to Gonzalez and quoted by Siemens), so I do (with a wry grin on my face) ask myself if the this paper (also dated 2004) is already obsolete? That said, I found much of this paper relevant and thought provoking: Siemens quotes Karen Stephenson's question "How can we continue to stay current in a rapidly evolving information ecology". This is a great question and one that I (feeling somewhat ignorant and overwhelmed) have asked myself quietly a number of times in the last few weeks. I feel pressure to be at least in front half of the pack with regards to shifts in educational approaches that reflect applications of technology and information literacy but when I access the huge amount of information out there, I wonder how anyone keeps current and still teaches full time. The whole process seems to require proficiency in "bandwagon" jumping in the sense that the application du jour might be obsolete or replaced in less than a single year of teaching. I have other (and I feel more important) things to focus on: like how am I going to get my head around general relativity and present it to my students in ways they will understand?

"Sure", some would say, "use the internet, set up a blog or a wiki, do a podcast" - "sure", I say, as well as cover the syllabus objectives completely, ensuring students understand, in less than the allotted time, because the kids are writing a standard exam in May.


I don't really need another learning theory. What I need are time-saving resources and ideas, appropriately leveled for my IB students, that scaffold other classroom experiences in developing relevant skills that will help them (the students) see success, and secure employment in future (yikes - see last paragraph). Oh and don't forget, they still need to learn about relativity (or maybe they don't??).
My connection here is that I don't have time for idealism (many full time classroom teachers don't).

I agree with the basic points of the article (to some extent - see paragraph below), I am trying to move with the times, but just when I feel I am current, something else crops up that (I am not trying to be funny here) makes me feel behind, ignorant, and an ineffective educator. Maybe I take it too personally?


Final point, the cynic strikes! The principles of connectivism have the subtle smell of the business model of education. In other words, working towards what a 21st century CEO wants in a graduate (see Alfie Kohn's excellent take on this) . I cringe at this thought wondering idealistically what happened to love of learning for the sake of just, well, learning.

Feb 14, 2009

And in related news

My top bloggies these last few days
Reading these posts makes me thankful for the fact that my working in an international school for the most part eliminates government meddle in education policy. International schools can be insular though and would do well to collaborate to establish a common blueprint for the integration of 21st century skills into curricular change for the future. Many hands make lighter work, and it seems like there are a number of independent inventors struggling to create a new wheel. I am still looking for a road map to change - steps to developing this blue print - so that I can more clearly see routes to desired outcomes, rather than feel a slave to all the hype (better get going teach or you are gonna fall behind). The ringleaders are all about blogging and sharing and collaborating but what I see is an exchange of ideas without the background of a structured framework. Where is this framework? Should it exist?

Feb 13, 2009

Year of the atheist!?


Yesterday was my 41st birthday. I have been alive 5 (soon to be 6) decades and sometimes feel like my life is only just starting to gain some momentum. I want this year to be transitional, a change from what was to something new. I guess, I am starting to feel (both psychologically and physically) a real sense of my own mortality.

I am going to start by declaring February 12th to be the new "New Year's eve". The chinese and muslims (and no doubt others) work on a lunar calendar (where the new year shifts back about 11 days in our julian calendar) each year. I don't propose anything so radical, we just entered the year of the ox in china, 2009 in the normal sense of timekeeping, my 42nd year is going to be the year of the atheist.

The year of the atheist represents a paradigm shift in my thinking and approach to getting what I want out of life. It is the year I explore my potential as a thinker, a doer, and somehow make a measure of my contributions to humanity. The choice of atheist makes sense to me for a number of reasons.

I am reading (and rereading) sections of The God Delusion by Richard Da
wkins and find this book to be inspirational in terms of my approach to Feb 13th 2009 - Feb 12th 2010. Dawkins is a courageous voice for science educators, free thinkers, and those sickened by living in a world where much evil and hate is brought on by ignorance and blind faith. I looked up "atheist" in the thesaurus on dictionary.com.

Note the reference: Roget's "21st Century" thesaurus. It interests me that "21st Century" seems to imply progress and is being thrown around with reference to "skills" in education circles like it is the reformation. Synonyms for "atheist" like "heathen", "infidel", "irreligionist" and "pagen" are hardly 21st century but rather reflect a more "inquisition" like attitude. Surely we have come further than that in today's society but the negative stigma associated with the word "atheist" is real, very evident, and for me, a stimulus for discussion (oh the controversy).

I have been a closet atheist for some time now. Dawkins has convinced me I no longer need to be that. I also think that the "you're an atheist" exclamation by others injects some much need controversy into my life. Not that I want to argue the existence of God with anyone (read Dawkins if you want to do this), it is just the fact that the statement symbolizes my desire to cultivate myself as a free thinker.

Other projects for the year of the atheist include my version of the 366 day photo project. Like others (this is not my idea), I am proposing to take and choose one picture for each day of my 42nd year. Picasa and Flickr are being debated right now as my technology medium of choice to keep this record.

I am coining terms that I hope enter mainstream vocabulary in the year of the atheist. "Blogged down" describes how many students feel in our classrooms right now as teachers jump on the 21st century bandwagon. I also hope I am the first person to go on record with the idea of a "digital footprint". More about this later.



Feb 8, 2009

How are my thoughts changing?

I know I need to find more time for this course than I actually have. Reflections take time and often (when under deadlines) are more "knee jerk" reactions than being actually reflective. I can now officially say I have skiied in China and after a weekend of sunshine, near misses and very spicy food, I find myself staring a large monitor screen wondering where to start with regard to the last week's readings.

I have been looking at the revised Bloom's Taxonomy for the 21st century. My perspective as an IB Science teacher questions "creating" being placed above "evaluating" as the latter is the area students struggle most with in laboratory situations but if I take the perspective that creating implies the production and development of a "novel" idea, then the scheme works well in my mind. The subtext of this comment should read "just because some element of design/planning is involved, does not necessarily mean my students are functioning at the top level of the HOTS". I take this position and apply it to the new "digital verbs" as they are integrated and commented on by Andrew Churches into this latest taxonomy revision. I struggled with this article but found it relevant to comments I made in my Where, When, How? post just recently. After being recently exposed to what appears to be a jump on the bandwagon free for all integration of anything ICT into our classrooms , I took the point of view of science educator and curriculum developer (what I know), and basically asked if there is an accepted scope and sequence for the introduction and development of ICT skills in our curriculum. Conveniently, the next article I read (Andrew Churches') gives me a list of 21st century skill action verbs pigeon holed into the revised developmental taxonomy. An excellent start but in some ways left a trying to ram a square peg into a round hole taste in my mouth. I am more confused than I was initially, but more determined than ever to find a scheme that makes sense. What I am getting at, is basically this:
1. I absolutely believe that educators must change with technology and society in order to understand our students, to best help them learn, to keep them engaged and to prepare them as best we can for the future.
2. I love teaching science through a curriculum that has an established skills progression embedded throughout and one that encourages inquiry.
3. I know ICT tools are critical and must be integrated BUT although enthusiastic about all the different excellent examples of ICT in classrooms I have seen recently, I believe this revolution needs structure, guidelines simplified for educators migrating in, consistency and educationally responsible practices.

The certificate program I am enrolled in is a start.

Feb 5, 2009

Where, when, how?


Yesterday I sat through an all staff meeting at my school and like many others got a glimpse of the future of curriculum planning and development. Our curriculum coordinator has done an admirable job of integrating the current thinking into a plan that includes the hiring of our school's first 21st century literacy coordinator. There were also elements of the 21st century revision of Bloom's taxonomy and a presentation of how our future curriculum mapping system might look.

Now, this is mostly moot for me as I am moving to a new school in August but I thought about it critically (some might say skeptically) and saw what is going to be a huge project that will be very current and I think difficult to implement. What got me thinking was that in the curriculum mapping/tracking system, there was a field to input the relevant 21st century skills that are supposedly being developed/assessed in that particular unit. The mapping function will allow tracking these skills from K-12 in all subject areas. Brilliant right? Hmmm.....

I tied this in with a discussion from a colleague in Manila who thinks kids are suffering from what I am going to call "Blogoverload". The requirements to blog are in many courses, as teachers jump to integrate the current trends. Related to this is the "Bloguniverse" I now live in and as an early citizen, have noticed that many blog posts are simply links to and comments about other people's blog posts. It is a good thing we are in a paperless age but that doesn't stop me from thinking that terabytes of storage, and gigabytes of bandwidth are the minimum requirements to support millions of school children who be-clogging the internet.

I am not trying to be negative, and some of you in the know may point out that I don't know what I am talking about but my point really is that there is some organization required here. There are definite progressions in terms of general and subject specific skills that we as educators are all aware of. For example "inquiry" in a science investigation looks different in grade 6 than in grade 11 and there are a number of developmental steps along the way. I am a firm believer that an effective curriculum in the current sense uses content as a vehicle to negotiate a skills continuum super highway. Is this type of guidance needed for all of this 21st century skill integration in our currently developing schools?

In a post entitled Kinder can do powerpoints too! , Silvia Tolisano links to a presentation regarding even young students doing interactive presentations. "Great" I say but as I stick to my guns about my position on "effective learning", I see a bigger picture of a mish mash of 21st century skills being incorporated in an inconsistent manner. Schools, slow down, think. Develop a skill set, categorize and create progressions, incorporate consistently in course development. I think this is harder than it sounds, the progressions in specific subjects (math, reading) are clear cut. Not so with ICT which has the added difficulty of always changing and also rapidly doing so.

Feb 4, 2009

Information overload?!

I am writing this in stages as I am slowly catching up with this course and feeling like I have already collected immense volumes of information about everything "21st century education". I set up my Google reader and as I careen at near light speed into the world of the Personal Learning Network, I need Googles to protect my eyes from the insane amount of information shrapnel emerging from my CRT (or should I say LCD).

In some ways, I find I love this thing (my PLN) in that it provides (and has the potential to provide further) all the information I could ever hope to want or need. On the other hand, I stare at the screen the same way I stare at shelves of books in Barnes and Nobel - not really knowing what is good, what isn't, how to discern, and in a paranoid kind of way, I worry about missing something.

I took a break for a few minutes there to reflect on what I have written and also browse the feeds in my Google reader - suggested by the COETAIL facilitators and decided that I need some kind of filter to sift through all the posts etc (they can't expect me to read all of them can they?) that only spits out the stuff I want to read (or I guess should read with regards to my course commitments). I actually think such a filter exists and it is called "time and experience" - something that is always at a premium in the world of teaching IB Physics and IB Chemistry.

Is this where I am headed? See overwhelmed (Jeff Utecht)

I know I need to find the time - for browsing - for finding what I like - tracking it - and booting out the rest. With regards to my course, I still don't know what I am looking for being just a mere a fledgling in the buzz of 21st century education and still a little hesitant to jump from the nest. I am guessing the pieces will fit together somehow and with a little patience, and some guidance, a tangible picture will form.

What I did find (somewhat randomly) was a great link to a piece of software that is FREE and an alternative to Starry Night for those of us that need to teach astronomy. Check out Stellarium. The most interesting blog post I read dealt with the false perception that our students are technologically competent. Read on here for more information (I especially like the examples and it made me think about the possibility that some of my expectations are unrealistic)